Understanding The Danger Of Buying Short Lease Properties And What To Do About It

Understanding Dangers Of Short Lease Properties
Disclosure: Clicking on links on this page may earn us a small commission. This helps us continue to produce free content and doesn't affect the price you pay.
Leasehold property is an interesting and often confusing ownership concept.

You don’t actually buy the building or the land it stands on – that remains the property of the freeholder. That’s the main difference between leasehold and freehold.

So, as a leaseholder, you acquire the right to occupy the property for a set length of time and under certain conditions, as set out in the Lease.

If you are looking to buy a leasehold flat, you should have a clear understanding of what this means in practice.

In particular, the length of the remaining lease at the point of purchase should be a key point of concern. Residential leases are typically assigned for a term of 99 years or 125 years, some can be for 999 years!

However, leasehold property, by definition, is a decreasing asset, and a property with a ‘short’ lease is particularly vulnerable. The good news is that the lease on your flat can be extended, so let’s take a look at how this can be achieved.

What’s the difference between freehold and leasehold property?

There are two different forms of legal ownership when it comes to property: freehold and leasehold. Freehold means that you own both the home and the land it stands on.

This means that the homeowner is responsible for all repairs, maintenance and costs relating to the property, and may alter the property and use it as they wish.

Leasehold means that you own the building but the land belongs to another person, legally known as the freeholder, but also referred to as the landlord.

A contract exists between the leaseholder and freeholder, which sets out certain rights and responsibilities for each party.

The freeholder has responsibilities towards the property, and can have extensive rights too. Flats and shared ownership properties are likely to be leasehold, although there is a growing trend for new build properties to be sold on a leasehold basis.

A leasehold is a long term agreement, usually lasting between 90 and 120 years. However, it can vary enormously. In some cases it may be as much as 999 years, or as short as 40 years.

The rights and responsibilities of leaseholds

Responsibilities Of Leaseholders

The exact rights and responsibilities of leaseholds varies with the property type. When it comes to flats, for example, leaseholders may have to pay an annual fee to the freeholder, known as a ground rent.

This can vary considerably in cost, depending on when the lease was last negotiated. In addition to this, leaseholders may be required to pay maintenance fees and annual service charges, and a portion of the building insurance.

Unless there is a ‘right to manage’ granted to the leaseholder, in the case of flats the freeholder is responsible for maintaining common parts of the building such as the entrance hall and staircases, plus the exterior walls and the roof of the property.

When it comes to both flats and houses, should the leaseholder want to make any substantial alterations to the property, for example, an extension, they will need to obtain permission from the freeholder. There may be other restrictions too, such as whether the leaseholder is allowed pets or whether they may sublet the property.

As can be seen, leasehold is very difference from freehold.

Enjoying this article? - Buying

Enjoying This Article?

Get more advice about buying property in your inbox

Get articles like this as downloadable PDFs when you join our email newsletter with regular updates and tips.

You can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

What’s classed as a short lease?

A short lease is one where there are limited years left on the contract. There’s no hard and fast answer to what’s classed as a short lease, but in some cases, anything below 80 years may be considered short. Certainly anything below 50 years would be considered a short lease.

Why are short leases a problem?

Graphs Of Relativity

Short leases are a problem for those seeking to sell their property, as it affects the value of the property.

There are a number of published graphs, known as Graphs of Relativity that shows the impact of various lease lengths on the value of the property. A lease of 60 years will reduce the value of a property by 10% compared to a property with a 99 year lease.

For those looking to buy a property, there can also be problems. Mortgage lenders are reluctant to lend when they consider the lease to be too short.

Where the lease is less than 80 years, it is common for would-be purchasers to insist that the leaseholder extend the lease before they complete the purchase.

The lease materially affects the value of your property

Leasehold value of property

No matter how attractive the property may be, having a short lease will inevitably affect its value. You may think that a 90-year lease is long enough – after all you will surely have left the property by then and it won’t affect you.

This is technically correct, however once the remaining years on the lease have reached 80 years or below, things can take on a new level of complexity.

Below 80 years, the property attracts a ‘marriage value’ which affects how much it will cost you to extend the lease.

The marriage value goes up as the lease goes down, which can make a lease extension prohibitively expensive – it pays to act fast before your lease slips to below 80 years.

It’s hard to get a mortgage on a short lease property

If you are thinking of buying a short lease property, you may encounter unsurmountable difficulties in obtaining finance.

Lenders will normally want a lease to run for at least 25 years beyond the end of the mortgage. With mortgages typically lasting 25 years, that’s a minimum length of 50 years.

However, in reality, lenders are likely to want a minimum of 80 years left on the lease to guarantee the value of the property they are lending against. 

In short, a flat with a short lease is much more difficult to sell.

The increasing loss of value makes it an unattractive proposition for both buyers and mortgage companies. If you are a seller, your market may well be restricted to cash buyers only.

Buying A Property? FREE Step-By-Step Platform

  • Bite-sized steps for buying and/or selling a property in the UK
  • Easy-to-follow explanations every step of the way
  • Clear actions to follow to progress your property transaction
  • Trackable progress so you know what to do next
  • Detailed informative articles related to every step you follow
Property Road Platform

You have a statutory right to extend your lease

Thankfully, you don’t have to be stuck with an inevitable property nightmare looming on the horizon. Under the Leasehold Reform, Housing and Urban Development Act 1993, leasehold owners have the statutory right to a lease extension.

While homeowners can ask the freeholder to extend the lease at any time, they usually need to have been a tenant for at least two years.

Once they have owned the property for two years, homeowners have the right to ask to extend the lease by 90 years on a flat, or 50 years on a house, provided that they are a qualifying tenant.

If the original lease was more than 21 years when they purchased the property, the homeowner is usually classed as a qualifying tenant.

The lease may be extended using the terms of the Leasehold Reform, Housing and Urban Development Act 1993, if applicable, or by private negotiation with the landlord.

There’s a set process to follow, and a premium to be paid to the freeholder which can be negotiated. For a quick look at how much your lease extension might cost and what the new value of your flat with an extended lease might be, take a look at this handy calculator.

You need to follow the correct lease extension process

Lease extension

While the benefits to the leaseholder are clearly set out under the terms of the Act, your freeholder may consider these to be unfavourable. As a consequence, they may suggest an exorbitantly high premium to protect their interests.

This is where the expert advice of an experienced property surveyor and solicitor will come in handy. Have a lease extension survey and formal valuation carried out, obtain professional guidance and instruct a specialist to negotiate on your behalf.

That way, you should be able to arrive at a premium that is mutually acceptable.

Your solicitor will serve the Initial Notice (Section 42 Notice) on your landlord which gets the legal process started. The freeholder has 2 months to serve a Counter Notice (Section 45 Notice). Once the premium and lease terms have been agreed, the lease extension will be completed and registered at the Land Registry.

There are alternatives to a statutory lease extension

If you don’t qualify for a statutory lease extension or prefer not to take advantage of your statutory rights, there are other ways. There’s nothing to stop you approaching your freeholder direct, at any point, and asking to extend your lease. 

While he is not obliged to grant you an extension, he may in fact prefer to deal with you outside of the Leasehold Reform legislation.

You may even find that your landlord is willing to offer you a cheaper price for an informal, non-statutory lease extension. While this may sound tempting, do check the suggested terms of this lease extension with a fine toothcomb, and certainly with professional assistance.

Be aware that any voluntary, negotiated lease extension won’t be bound by the Leasehold Reform Act, which may leave you with onerous yet legally binding clauses that work in the freeholder’s favour.

How much will it cost to extend the lease?

Cost Of Extending A Lease
Image by Quince Creative

While there are calculators available, there is no set amount when it comes to extending the leasehold contract. The cost will depend very much on the property and its value, and will be negotiated between the freeholder and the leaseholder.

The way that the cost is calculated is in line with Schedule 13, Part II of the Leasehold Reform, Housing and Urban Development Act 1993.

When calculating the premium, a number of factors are taken into account including:

  • The reduction in the value of the landlord’s interest; i.e. the difference between the value of his interest now and the value of his interest after the granting of the additional 90 years on the new lease, as the entire new lease will be at ‘peppercorn rent’ (no ground rent payable).
  • The landlord’s share of the ‘marriage value’, defined below, if the current lease has less than 80 years left.
  • Compensation for loss arising from the granting of the new lease.

Reduction of the landlord’s interest

The reduction of the value of the landlord’s interest is considered to be the loss of income arising from the loss of ground rent for the remainder of the original term, and the loss due to the additional 90 years wait to take legal possession of the property.

Enjoying this article? - Buying

Enjoying This Article?

Get more advice about buying property in your inbox

Get articles like this as downloadable PDFs when you join our email newsletter with regular updates and tips.

You can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Marriage value

Marriage value is calculated as the potential for increase in the value of the flat that occurs as the result of the granting as the new lease. As already discussed the remaining length of the lease can have a considerable effect upon the value of the affected property.

The above mentioned Act lays out that any profit must be split equally between landlord and leaseholder. This potential profit is calculated using the knowledge and experience of valuers from the local area to assess the probable increase in value.


It is unlikely that the landlord will be granted compensation, as they will retain the freehold. One potential reason that they might be able to claim compensation is if there was the potential for redevelopment of the land, which they have now lost.

Reaching an agreement

Agreeing A Lease Extension

There is no requirement for a formal valuation of the property to be obtained, but it would be sensible for both parties to seek their own valuation. If both parties are happy to do so, then an agreement can be reached informally.

However, if this is impossible, then there is a formal procedure, which begins when the leaseholder makes an offer in the form of a Tenant’s Notice. This does not need to be the same as the valuation, and the tenant is not legally required to disclose any valuation. 

If the landlord is not happy with the offer made, they may make a Counter-Notice with their own asking price.

Tribunal decisions

Ideally, the two parties will negotiate a premium between them. However, if they are unable to reach an agreement, they may make an application to the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) within prescribed timescales. This tribunal will listen to both parties and determine all of the above issues relating to the premium.

For leaseholders it’s worth noting that stamp duty is applicable if the premium is over £125,000, as it would when purchasing a property to live in.

The leaseholder is also liable for their own and landlord’s reasonable professional costs. These can be significant and, at a minimum, are likely to include solicitors and surveyors.

Buying the freehold of a leasehold property

A leaseholder has the right to ask the landlord to sell them the freehold at any time, under the Leasehold Reform Act of 1967, if they meet qualifying criteria.

There are different rules and procedures depending on the type of property. If the property is in a block of flats, then you will buy a share of the freehold with the other tenants in the building.

If it is a standalone property, then you may buy the freehold outright. In situations where the landlord wishes to sell the freehold of a block of flats, they are required to offer the leaseholders first refusal.

The sale of the freehold may be performed informally or formally. Where the sale is agreed informally, there is no access to the Tribunal.

However, if the parties opt to follow the formal route, there are procedures and timescales laid out in law that determine the price and terms of the purchase if the two parties are unable to reach an agreement.


  • Jason Taylor

    Jason is a former estate agent who now splits his time between managing his own property investment portfolio and writing for Property Road.

    View all posts
How To Get ANY Property Below Asking Price

Killer Questions When Buying A Property


How To Get ANY Property Below Asking Price

When you subscribe to our email newsletter. Plus, receive a 7-day crash course on how to buy a property in double-quick time.

You can unsubscribe at any time.
See our Privacy Policy.